Ben Stein has an interesting on Intelligent Design, I know it's on Netflix streaming, called Expelled. It's worth taking a viewing.
I am not on board with taking evolution theory out of schools, but I don't see an issue with intelligent design, or a 'creator-based' theory being offered as "this is something that some people believe". There's not wrong with taking a "top level" evaluation of the different theories.
what 'creator' do you teach? Christian God and Adam/eve? Allah? or Mormon's view of Jesus as the one who just 'organized' what was already there? If you teach one, you have to teach them all.. because the one you are teaching, might not be the one some students believe in..
this is why I think this is where the church should play their role..